Our Site

Our landmarked 1844 Church is the fourth on this site,

succeeding our 1680, 1715 and 1787 Churches.

Our ministry dates to 1656, the Congregation to 1665. During worship you might find yourself sitting next to a direct descendant of a Revolutionary War hero, or of our original "Voorlezer." 

The Annex was built in 1898 as the Sunday School.

Its Architect, Oscar S. Teale, was a magician-associate of Houdini.

Our Burial Place, the oldest in continuous use on Staten Island,

is among the ten oldest in New York City.

Our Church and Burial Place are each Landmarks

and nominated for National Historic Site

See us on Visit Staten Island/reformed-church/

Donate to Save our Shared History

In addition to being the final resting place of some of Staten Island’s most notable figures, it contains tombstone carvings so distinctive that it received separate Landmark status.